IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The 5 Shades of Orange]

Orange?

Can't really see the point in restricting the shades to one colour, its doesn't add anything. As usual for collabs of seperates some very basic stuff gets through on the coat tails of good work.

Made me smile a little, some good animation and all good sounds in there. All well put together.

JKR responds:

Restricting the colors allows, or rather FORCES, the animator to make different choices than they might otherwise. It's a great exercise to improve things you would never even think about with full color. You have to balance things more, and really look at the whole picture since you are limited. Anyway, glad it made you smile some, because after all that's the whole point of doing amusing animations! Cheers.

[Rise and shine]

Disappointing

Nice start- goes to nothing.

Lovely music, nice birds, sun starts to rise...

then reaches a flat top? as it rises further something spoils the line on the left, then it abruptly ends replaced by what I would call scribble and nonsense. Worse, the lovely music goes on when the rest has stopped.

this lovely music deserves a full, quality video, but this isn't it.

I would like to see smooth quality images, maybe expressing waking up and early morning, sunrise. life setting about its day routine etc.
You have the ability- please do it some time.

TreasurePlanet responds:

thanks for the thoughtful review.

this was not a project meant to be stressed over and planned.
This was to relax and just... do whatever I want.
What im saying is that there was not supposed to be a story.

but i will take your review into consideration for future projects.

cheers/
-Spacecase

[animation scraps]

I suppose...

... its just about good enough art/animation to keep, despite not being anything really. You obviously have great potential and I look forward to seeing proper complete work from you in due course, with sound, colour, length and a plot that shows PERSONALITY, which will make us care about the characters, not just action.

Then you can delete this scrap that doesn't really belong here!

Until then, good luck, keep working!

axl-ryder responds:

you're absolutely right, and when I submit the real thing I'll probably delete this, but for now I just wanted to have something for people to click on if they happen to view my account. Thanks for the critique.

[Chris and Harry (Parody)]

Not too bad

Not everyone knows Chris and Harry. A link would have been good. Animation basic; art OK.

SmallSSaaMM responds:

www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/468840
Special for you :D

[The Bomb Squad Christmas]

This could be a whole new Flash Crew- the BS

Taz Bomb, Bob Bomb, GaryGrenade bomb, Strawberry Bomb, Pineapple Bomb, Blastmas Day submissions, I see it all!

The sound isn't great, but you can hear it and its funny. The voices are GREAT. and the poem is good too.

This deserves more recognition.

NinjaWabbit responds:

haha thanx!
Yeah i plan on making more and the quality will be far more improved now that i have my animations being outputted into .swf's rather than movie type files then being converted into .swf's.
Also preloaders will be eventually added as well.
I found out what my problem was with projects not saving so that now worx too.
I wish i had those animations, i made, saved as projects because then i could have outputted them as .swf's (which would have atleast made the artwork better, and down the road i could have redid the audio on good equipment) and then they would really shine. All it would have took was a computer restart or mess up and then i would've lost any of the animations that I've made.
But sadly there's no way to fix them up other than a total do over whilst trying to stick to the regular awesomeness that made them shine.
Trial & Error all the way....
I'm all about quality and substance.
Thanx for the compliments & more animations are in the worx....

["EXTINCT"]

Its very good

Obviousiy, the animation, art etc is in the top bracket for NG. It has a clear message of warning against our treatment of wild creatures, so the flash has entertainment and purpose. You wrap us up into the quiet story of a wild kitten's everyday life, then jump us into the sad reality of our treatment of wild animals.

There are, however, details of improvement. As has been said, more variety in expression for the kitten would be good. Studying the movement of butterflies a little more- their bodies don't go down as the wings go up quite like that and they have a destintive zigzag/random element to their flight paths to avoid predetors, which is part of what subtly identifies them as butterflies. I felt that a few scenes were a little slow/drawn out- tho I know that is very difficult and a matter of personal taste.
Finally, it is a shame in a work of such effort and quality that the only text isn't better english.

I note that others have queried the conection between making animals into pets and making them extinct. Although the pet trade- killing mothers to get their babies etc. DOES risk extinction, this movie does not make that connection clear. Some kind of More Info button, taking the viewer to a couple of lines of well-written sentances (in 2 languages?) explaining your thoughts and links to one or two most relevent sites would make this movie SO much more significant. If you wish to work on this movie, please PM me and I will discuss it with you in detail and support you- its worth it.

Front Page, please!!!!!

manuelberja responds:

thanks! :)

will send you PM!

[my first animation.]

very limited

This is very samey, it has nothing new about it and I am sure it is NOT made by Stigthomas only, I am sure the art is mostly made by others and sprite-animated by you. I have nothing against sprites, but be honest if that is the case.

Very few animations without sound pass judgment. Explore what does and doesn't get through judgment here.
With work, your existing skill could produce good stuff with sound, music, a proper story with personality and and, a Stop/replay and proper credits in the movie.
Continue working.

stigthomas responds:

i will become better but i didnt steal any of this stuff. i made all by myself

[Space Nazis In Space]

soso-

might have been quite good/funny if I could hear the words. Otherwise, it is an entertaining collection of images/bit of story.

CorpseGrinderClock responds:

You should turn up your speakers!