IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Behind the Magic]

Yes!

Well summed up. Funny.

stoners-lunchbox responds:

Could've been worse. I could've actually tried to really take the piss out of the Clock Crew. But i didn't for one particular reason. If you wanna find out what that is simply look up RottenPrune's user information on the ClockCrew.cc website.

Thanks for watching!

[RCC - Who is shenkel?]

Looks good

Looks good, sounds good.
I don't really understand it.
First of all, I have never heard of RCC, they must be pretty obscure, I've seen an awful lot of movies here. Which means that most people will have no idea who is involved.

I don't really understand the technicalities but I think this is evidence, not proof.

Furthermore, is it shenkel or shekel?

Actually, I liked it and voted 3/5 cos its such a change from the usual in-jokes within and between NG crews, which are so crude.

I don't really understand this whole hacking business, but I can imagine its pretty upsetting. If people started producing bogus DS stuff, I'd be pretty annoyed.

RCChacked responds:

Thanks first off for your coment. You are right! This is more like evidence than proof. So yeah!

Thanks!

[[C9C] General Pershing 1]

Nice intro etc.

It all looked very good. I've never heard of you guys and I assume you are new. I hope you have some ideas that are original and not just CC clones otherwise you will not last here.

Sorry I can't give you anything much in the way of score but really the movie itself had nothing to it- obivously you know that. I don't want to sit though loading up a load of music I could hear anywhere unlees there is something to go with it. If you had just had a selection of slides, a little bit of animation and a few links of info on Pershing I would probably have passed it.

I clicked on your site and found that like all the others its just a member/forum thing with nothing to tell us who you are and what your plans/aims are. Another disappointment.

Welcome to the Portal anyway. I hope I can support some of your work in the future.
Best Wishes to the Camera Cult from the Dragons & Spirits.
IceDragon64

LoquatCamera responds:

Thank you.

[Star Wars Episode X]

Disappointing

Its started good- not great but 3/5 or something. I like SW and some of the graphics were interesting etc. It was a bit funny and I looked forward to what was happening, then it just stopped.
If it were in judgement I would 0 it to help make you finish it properly. Please get on and do so. Please do NOT submit unfinished movies- Toms advice specifically advises you against it

towerdefense responds:

i'm sorry i just wanted to get a lot of opinions out of people... some people want me to keep it up but should i take it off? i've heard what people think now

[Piece of Tape]

OK

Its not Disney but its all right.
+ It made me smile a little and it doesn't look bad. You say its amateur, but the graphics look a lot like some of the stuff they use in advertising etc.
Its a nice small file

-needs the hit sound.

franzgunkel responds:

Wasn't really shooting for Disney, but i'm sure they wouldn't be happy to know that you compared me to them.

[Giant]

Good

Interesting. different. Eccentric in a Salad Fingers weird way.
Sound not perfect, its a little too close to the mic or something.
Based on a true story?

Fische responds:

Yeah. It's true. The giant even looks like that and everything.

[Space Shots 2]

Very Good,funny

+ good animation, sound, art.
+funny
+loved the idea of transposing the images of alien with chick to show the birds point of view.
+the tones of the voices indicated neatly the gist of what was being said.

GUTOONs responds:

Thanks,
GU

[Animation With Chalk]

Probably not the right place

I imagine there are places that would really appreciate the art style of this, but I doubt NG is one of them. Personally it did nothing for me and seemed more or less pointless.
If you are not succesful here, try somewhere like DeviantArt.

Chrispy responds:

Well, thank you for your honesty, it was really just expirimental, I ask you to please check out my other stuff, it is much better with a story and humor and it's longer and all :)

[Just Like A Video Game]

Good

Nice little story.

OK art
OK animation
Good sound
I didnt understand the fried egg.

Butzbo responds:

the fried egg is a wink to my first submitted movie : "Solar burn", the same purple guy explodes in that short, becoming a fried egg.
heh. Glad you liked it!

[Simian]

Patchy

The central movie sketch is quite interesting, the rest were OK. The extras were lame, just one bit of this and one bit of that seemed hardly worth bothering with.
You warned us about the sound so I won't take away anything for that, but I wont give you much either.

The scribble is unneccesary and not good.
The C word is unneccesary and disapointing.

Not too bad and a bit different

AdamJack responds:

Cheers for the review, it was very helpful. I'm a bit edgy when animating and tend to do things with out thinking twice. I wanted to express some of my edginess into the piece but I know now that I went over the top. Thanks again.