IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Serg Epic]

Actually...

despite being too simple and pointless for me to want us to keep it here, it doesn't look too bad- it kinda works! If it had some music and maybe played about in a fun way with colours etc. I might even protect it

[What do Monkeys Eat?]

Ha!

Silly little thing, but I smiled, so I clicked the 2 button. More talent in the Notes than the submission, but hey, it works OK, it looks OK, Music OK, so what the hell... ;)

[Voyager (with subs)]

Very Good!

Good animation, art, story, music etc.

Thank you very much for translating it into english subtitles for us. The english isn't perfect, but its good enough. I was amused by your leaves on us humans!

The story isn't really that original- in fact it is quite predictable, but that is OK. It is typical dark Newgrounds humour anyway.

What about a sequel ? You can't create such wonderful aliens and just forget about them? You must explore more about what mistakes they would make based on the record we sent- what if a hand in the air has a different meaning to them?

You won a prize, not a price!

[Yuki pistol loop]

Its all good...

...enough quality, but why would we want to watch this or preserve it here? Its just a snipet of something. Make the movie; tell the story make the game even- at least add the sound, the credits, the Stop/Replay.

Kayjun responds:

tru dat its just practice

[Day 14: Steak]

A screamer, basically

Dissappoining. I know Tom took it out of the Rules, but its still true what he said- It was funny once, but now its lame.

That kind of language in the Notes doesn't help either. People will hate what they hate, swearing at them will not make them like you. In the past many of my Clock friends were determined to be friendly to their critics, so I am not impressed by this tone.

That said the animation etc is OK and I've seen worse, its even slightly funny

ClockOfBlob responds:

It's not a screamer. It's steak clock. Finding you.

[LL - Sofa]

Really good twists!

Great effects, good art, good sounds, OK music. Nice details- hands, expressions etc.

Some great ideas there. I wouldn't change anything (except to my taste in music, maybe!)

[Protocols of elder Atoms]

Funny

The voice! The accent, its great, though rather hard to hear.

I like the whole thing from art to sounds.

Shame there are not any more AA subs- come back you guys!

[Autocomplete]

Yes!

I didn't know it was called autocomplete, but yeah, its kinda funny what crops up. This is an amusing collection- is it based on real autocompletes?

Funny stuff, great sounds, speech. Animation OK, does the job. Some of the layers have little white edges, where they don't cover properly, but thats common and not important.

You need to Stop and Replay and full credits within the movie- sound etc.

Do more!

Ramsimation responds:

yeha most of them are based on real autocompletes, failblog had a collection of autocomplete fails ;D

[Deforestation]

Great message

Good music, OK art.

animation simple and rather crude, but got the message across.

I think it would have been better with some sounds as well as the music.

Music should be credited in the movie.

[- Historcial Relevance -]

a bit funny

but not very. Its OK and the acheivement unlocked thing is quite good. Its got OK sound and there's nothing really wrong with it.

I would prefer to see the title spelt right, though perhaps y'all wouldn't.

Sorry, I doubt you will keep a Page up on Wikipedia in the forseable future, but as I have said more than once in the talk page of the Newgrounds page, if you guys just keep building your crew into something significant beyond Newgrounds itself, your time will come. Meanwhile do check out the CC on Wikigrounds, where we have a substantial Page for you.

Best Wishes to the CC from the Dragons & Spirits