IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sherbert the Cat 2]

Good

+Good art
+good animation
+funny- some nice ideas in there

I felt the mice were rather lame- they didn't really DO much they were a bit of a cop out- really just copy the picture, then dont bother.
its good, though, I enjoyed it. the music and the internet!

Go and watch some classic cartoons critically. Study how they get their laughs, the sounds and music blend etc. make them even better.

Poor Sherbert, he is just doing his job but Tom doesn't look pleased.

You have the basic abililty and with the added support of Sherbert fans you can realy clean up.

[Tro's offline Trauma]

Good, funny

I wouldn't say it was unfinished cogwheel brain explosion is an ending, however it is true one could do more with it.
+art good
+animation good
+sounds funny!
+idea/story funny

Unless you wanted to build on it, I wouldn't change it.

[Total Eclipse]

Very mixed

+Proper story
+ Some good sounds and voices
+ Some OK art and animation

-Some poor sounds
-Artwise its some good pics mixed with scribble

You need to study the final result over and over before submitting- preferably with honest reviews by friends first.

Storywise I think you are assuming a lot of people's ability to understand what is going on. Again, talk it through with people who DON'T already know about this series.

This has considerable potential- please make it the best you can.

Best wishes,
Ice

Ice

[Save Tom Fulp!!]

Fun, funny

Liked it. It had the CC charm and silly style I have grown fond of.
I liked the Mars bar joke and the selection of music.

Didn't like the loop at the end much, though, it looks lousy, seeing the spaceship fall back each time.

Courgy responds:

Yeah I got lazy with the spaceship =3

[shity pc]

Good but mixed

Art/animation Mixed quality

3D angles/ perspective mixed up but good effort

Ideas Good

Text not very good english

Don't like the title. Sh1tty is spelt thus anyway

Music options good

Minodragon responds:

Yes I don't like the titel either. If you have a better one? ;)

And yes I am dislectic. ;'(

But what do you mean with mixed quality?

[I don't speak english!]

OK, quite funny

simple but effective

Speek/speak.

[Bring a Condom on a Date?]

Women!

This is SO right! You can't win! Yeah! just like that!

Beautifully done.
Good art
Good animation
Good sound
Its all good
I wouldn't change it!

[BTA Collection: Viruses]

There is a tradition on NG...

...whereby if you are the final voter, the 200th person, who gets the 'Saviour' video when the movie is protected, that you review it... So I will.

It shows some potential with a little humour and theres noting wrong with what little there was, but really there is not much to it. You should have submitted a small collection of them or made this one longer. It is not really as described in your notes as there is only a single sprite. It would be much better if you told people what to do to prevent this catastrophe occuring- a humourous, imaginary anti-virus program would be OK, watch it splat the wizard guy.

I always feel a little embarassed when I am told I am the Saviour when I actually blammed something- Well I gave it 1/5 and I think you know you were lucky to scrape through. If I were a statwhore I would have voted 0 and I might have made all the difference.
Anyhow you made it- count yourselves lucky and please make the rest of the series with a bit more time, patience and effort.
There is nothing wrong with Flash MX, I never use any of the features of Flash 8! GEt some experience now on NG. Get some inspiration and read some of the tutorials here as well. Come back with length, style, detail, story, humour and proper credits. then watch your scores rise!
Best Wishes,
Ice

[El3]

Because its in spanish...

... I don't understand it very well. It certainly would be nice if you could put in English subtitles or just some kind of introduction would help.
However, I can see that the art is OK and so is the small amount of animation. It has length and appears to have some kind of story.
It was good enough for me to watch all of it and WANT, at least to understand it.
Mainly I have written this review, though, to counteract the unreasonably poor review score it has in general.