IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Space Shots 2]

Very Good,funny

+ good animation, sound, art.
+funny
+loved the idea of transposing the images of alien with chick to show the birds point of view.
+the tones of the voices indicated neatly the gist of what was being said.

GUTOONs responds:

Thanks,
GU

[Animation With Chalk]

Probably not the right place

I imagine there are places that would really appreciate the art style of this, but I doubt NG is one of them. Personally it did nothing for me and seemed more or less pointless.
If you are not succesful here, try somewhere like DeviantArt.

Chrispy responds:

Well, thank you for your honesty, it was really just expirimental, I ask you to please check out my other stuff, it is much better with a story and humor and it's longer and all :)

[Just Like A Video Game]

Good

Nice little story.

OK art
OK animation
Good sound
I didnt understand the fried egg.

Butzbo responds:

the fried egg is a wink to my first submitted movie : "Solar burn", the same purple guy explodes in that short, becoming a fried egg.
heh. Glad you liked it!

[-failure-]

its OK

Its basic but it works. The music thing at the beginning is what makes it. It gives it the uplifting atmosphere. Then the branch thing halfway down made my finger hover over the 3/5 6/10 mark- for a plain black and white stick sketch- not bad at all.
you might find a better sound for the very end.

[Lightning short (Stick)]

sorry, I don't get it

I dont like stick fighting all that much, we get tons of it here and it all looks so much the same. This one had some bolts of weird looking lightning, but the bolts didn't make any sense to me- why did they strike? However short a movie is I like it to have some kind of story or at least development.

[Simian]

Patchy

The central movie sketch is quite interesting, the rest were OK. The extras were lame, just one bit of this and one bit of that seemed hardly worth bothering with.
You warned us about the sound so I won't take away anything for that, but I wont give you much either.

The scribble is unneccesary and not good.
The C word is unneccesary and disapointing.

Not too bad and a bit different

AdamJack responds:

Cheers for the review, it was very helpful. I'm a bit edgy when animating and tend to do things with out thinking twice. I wanted to express some of my edginess into the piece but I know now that I went over the top. Thanks again.

[Radioactive - By Jorgon]

nice

good music, good timing good art and animation. Nice simple message.

Nice healthy green grass looked odd after the explosion. otherwise fine.

Maybe you need to team up somehow with the guy that produced the movie Nuclear Waste that is going through judgement this evening! Maybe see if you can get a few more and make a website.

Maybe you could put in a few info links at the end.

Jorgon responds:

Oh man, I can't believe I left the green grass in... I could swear I changed it... Oh well. Thanks for the review anyways.

[Catfish]

Please sort it out

Its will be worth it, with proper sound. I don't get the ending, but maybe thats just me. It looks great.

[Nuclear Power...]

I agree with Dorque

Its OK, its got sound its got humour its got a little story and its got RANDOM!

Theres probably more you could do with the sound and you should credit Queen within the movie.
You might try putting in a couple of relevent links- nuclear power/dumping wikipedia, the right page of Greenpeace or something, but its OK as it is.

[Microsoft Hell]

Basic but OK

I think it just needs one more sentance:
"I can help you writing a suicide note."