IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Star Wars Episode X]

Disappointing

Its started good- not great but 3/5 or something. I like SW and some of the graphics were interesting etc. It was a bit funny and I looked forward to what was happening, then it just stopped.
If it were in judgement I would 0 it to help make you finish it properly. Please get on and do so. Please do NOT submit unfinished movies- Toms advice specifically advises you against it

towerdefense responds:

i'm sorry i just wanted to get a lot of opinions out of people... some people want me to keep it up but should i take it off? i've heard what people think now

[Eres Veneno ++]

Its good, but...

I don't think its that great. Its doesn't make all that much sense to me. I know its part of a series etc but still...

I give it 4/5 for its look and animation. It tried to follow it and it was kinda interesting but not top 50 material imo. No way does it match, say Skaijo's work, for example, which has more detail, more character and development of sound.

[Piece of Tape]

OK

Its not Disney but its all right.
+ It made me smile a little and it doesn't look bad. You say its amateur, but the graphics look a lot like some of the stuff they use in advertising etc.
Its a nice small file

-needs the hit sound.

franzgunkel responds:

Wasn't really shooting for Disney, but i'm sure they wouldn't be happy to know that you compared me to them.

[Giant]

Good

Interesting. different. Eccentric in a Salad Fingers weird way.
Sound not perfect, its a little too close to the mic or something.
Based on a true story?

Fische responds:

Yeah. It's true. The giant even looks like that and everything.

[Throwback the Duck Ep. 1B]

very good

but not great. I don't really get it all that well. I am following the series, but I really don't get the long drawn out angry oriental guy bit. I guess it might mean more if I was into computer games.
Hopefully it will make more sense later on.

[Space Shots 2]

Very Good,funny

+ good animation, sound, art.
+funny
+loved the idea of transposing the images of alien with chick to show the birds point of view.
+the tones of the voices indicated neatly the gist of what was being said.

GUTOONs responds:

Thanks,
GU

[Animation With Chalk]

Probably not the right place

I imagine there are places that would really appreciate the art style of this, but I doubt NG is one of them. Personally it did nothing for me and seemed more or less pointless.
If you are not succesful here, try somewhere like DeviantArt.

Chrispy responds:

Well, thank you for your honesty, it was really just expirimental, I ask you to please check out my other stuff, it is much better with a story and humor and it's longer and all :)

[Just Like A Video Game]

Good

Nice little story.

OK art
OK animation
Good sound
I didnt understand the fried egg.

Butzbo responds:

the fried egg is a wink to my first submitted movie : "Solar burn", the same purple guy explodes in that short, becoming a fried egg.
heh. Glad you liked it!

[-failure-]

its OK

Its basic but it works. The music thing at the beginning is what makes it. It gives it the uplifting atmosphere. Then the branch thing halfway down made my finger hover over the 3/5 6/10 mark- for a plain black and white stick sketch- not bad at all.
you might find a better sound for the very end.