IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Star Wars: Rebel Alliance]

Very good but...

clearly could be better.

+good graphics, I liked the tiny close-ups

-needs proper credits
-ending very abrupt

[Madness Antipathy]

Good, but not no.1

-this madness stuff is getting SO samey, besides, which timing of men just standing there, waiting to be killed, with guns in their hands is lame.

+However, there were details of thought and humour in there.
+there is a thread of story going through the series.

I assume once it has been judged by its post-judgement views the score will settle down to something more realistic. At present it has been inflated by stat whores fifening it through judgement. It is not in the same league as There She Is or Bracknwood.

[fucked for fun]

I didn't even like the music...

I don't like such languge in the title.
No matter how they rate the music, we all see the title.

It has nothing to it really- no real animation no length interest etc.

[Short - The Bush Song]

Great content but...

-not much skill otherwise.

-limited animaiton, basic lip sync.

-Poor art

However, Im glad its been protected cos i agree with the song SO much!

[Zombie Groceries Revolt!]

I did protect it but...

I think the guy before me was right it bleongs on Youtube or something.

You needed at least a little bit of Weird Al singing, other wise its just the intro to Beat it.

It was funny

[LoZ: Ocarina of Time p1]

Not bad

+length
+story
+neat, tidy and credited

-This is obviously written for people who already know The Legend of Zelda. You would do better for outsiders like me if you gave us a bit of introduction.
If the story is based on Ocarina of Time, the sounds come from OoT and the Sprites come from OoT, then what part is yours- is there anything in it which is actually original?
If you take a look at MEKoftheMEKKingdom's work you will see what I mean.
For example- He takes images and traces them into Flash. then he can zoom in and see a real picture, instead of pixelated scribble.
the trouble with sprites is that they alway look tiny or pixelated.
Like I said, its not bad, but there just is a limit to the credit I could give you for this work.
Two small errors in the text: Thou hast returned; Thy slumber
Best Wishes, Ice

ruffyreborn responds:

Thank you for the Textual errors.

Yeah I know it isnt very original, but Im kind of doing this to teach myself. The only original concepts I used were using ALLTP sprites for Oot, and maybe changing the script a tin bit.

[Sevenstar Surprise Party]

Well done! you made me laugh!

So far this is the only seven-star i have protected today.

Because this was meanigful to those who know nothing about 7 star- except that he is 17 today- and it wasn't totally messy.

It was hard to hear the voices properly, but I got the simple idea. its very basic and I might not have protected it on another day, but compared to the rest its quite good.

Happy 17th birthday to Seven Star from
IceDragon of the Dragons & Spirits

FatBadger responds:

:)