IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Five Second Collab]

Ten versions of Meh is still meh, I'm afraid.

[Codex Black - Teaser]

I don't like teaser/trailers much. People make them and often don't make the movie. 3/5 is as high as I give, but it appears to be quality and I am sure it works.

[Snake Town]

I like it. Lots going on, lots of good ideas. Very good art; simple, but adequate animation. Pleasant, and apt music. OK, sound.

I was hoping for more to actually happen. I think this as high as I could give for something that has no actual story. The X says he wanted longer, but I think I would have got bored.

[Late night sketch]

Not my thing, but its OK. Clearly some art talent. Not keen to encourage what amounts to trying to sell your art here.

LargoMinus responds:

Oh yeah, I forgot that it says it’s for sale at the end. It sold already. I’ll cut that part out of the video here soon. Thanks for letting me know

[Running in the forest]

We don't want your tests. This is judgement. Come back with complete flash, with sound and quality.

[B is B-ack]

Well at least its actually an animation ! ;)

Best wishes to the CC from the DS, as ever.

[a very clockish halloween]

Its good- its very clock, full of the right refs and story. good sound, it is, indeed a very Clockish Halloween.

I don't like buttons that are only the text as the hit button, its irritating. Give it a proper hit square.

Why the link to 2007?

Credits. If you are going to have credits, they should be more complete. Music, would be the obvious one, maybe sounds. What did RobertClock do ?

[Clock Wipe]

All boxes ticked, art animation, great and somehow amusingly appropriate music and humour.

[Valentine's Day F L O W E R]

Now here I can appreciate the quality and despite not knowing who is in the pic, you have given enough info and style for me to guess that this is someone expelled from the Crew. Its a nice bit of story and as well as the humour, it is, to us outside the Crew, a worthy tragic little story of Valentines Day as well.
The use of that vintage crackle, which somehow works to add to the scene tips it up into an unheard of 3.5 from me to you !

Time to stop calling good work like this "Genre: Spam." Its not, well done.

[Clocks, Please]

Everything is in order, as far as I know- although I don't know the reference. Strange speaking, but I assume that's all about the parody. The alien echoeyness is quite earie.

Quite good art and adequate animation.

We spoke recently about the scores people give. You need to bear in mind that to you something seems very good- ie over 3/5 because it is a parody of something you know. If one doesn't know it, its not going resonate and result in the high scores unless something is more-than-good to general watchers.

Thus Dragons will always score IHR hightly not just out of loyalty to a Dragon, but because they know the real Ibby- does that make sense ?

To me this ticks the basic boxes- 1.5 - 2. Has some story/has reasonable quality 2-2.5 and entertains -in this case has humour- 3.