IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Lost Robot]

Good stuff

Good graphics, nice details, not all that much animation, but I liked the backgrounds.
Nice, appropriate music

Sorry to be pedantic, but please put that spelling right- boiling, not bioling ash, it really spoils otherwise good text.

icaforp responds:

Thanks for the good review. I will change the text thank you for pointing that out! I apologize to everyone for my poor spelling.

[LL- Merry Xmas from Grey]

Its OK

Im glad Maylee understood it, because I didn't figure out what it was. A few little sounds would be good. Shame about the collab., this is OK, but it doesn't stand on its own all that well.

The Dragon/Spirit Alliance is Ock neutral and only votes on merit.

[Trichinosis]

Good, intelligent Flash

Excellent images and information.

The material is very much up my street and I hope you have given many people cause to think.

I gave it 4/5 because there isn't actually much animation, but it was borderline 5 and I might come back and vote 5 some other time!

Nice to see quality flash with details, good sound and music and credits etc.

could you insert just a few more frames to read the info about heathcare, other wise the timing was perfect.
Well done,

Thank you

[BB: Paper Samurai]

Good Mickey take

Nice action, liked the re-appearing pencil. the weird semi-storyline is very ock.

Music appropriate, would have been better with a few sounds, otherwise, it was everything it should be.

The Dragon/Spirit Alliance is ock neutral and votes only on merit.

Paper-Samurai responds:

Well, thank you for your kind review!

[Nick 1: My heart]

Style

I had to replay it a few times to take it all in and try to understand it. Some of the details flash by pretty fast.

Wierd butterfly thing!- excellantly random- random is good, we like random!

I take it that was a cigarette and gum at the beginning?

That heart thing reminds me all too much of me!

I see you are a Londoner- so are we.

[Short Sheep Sketch 2]

Sorry, I didn't understand it.

and I can't say I liked it much either- not half as good as Sheep1
However, I am glad to read that you are working on sound effects. I don't do sound myself- I mostly do backgrounds and writing, but I know how important it is.

I look forward to your longer work- make every one the best you can.

Take your time and get your friends to check/review your work- it is very hard to see your own mistakes.
I know I can be harsh, but I review almost everything I see, including around 100 reviews on blammed work which is not in my stats.

[Short Sheepsketch]

Yes, it was funny!

Thats, better! Now I can see your ability

I liked the tongue and the messing around with the NG preloader.

The aftermessages were also funny.

If you get to see our compilation- Kentucky Fried Flash- please don't think I am copying you- I wrote "How not to cut down a tree three months ago!

Sound effects would deffinately help- especially a moment of chainsaw sound, which I'm told is an easy sound to find on the web.
Also a cracking/falling tree sound.

This would help to make up for the rather basic graphics and take you to another level.

This is fun- do more!

[Sheep no1:Bigger than me!]

Adequate

Not much to it, but it was OK.

A bit of background wouldn't go amiss. Sounds too - a bleat, a bang etc. Replay buttons encourage people to look again and sometimes see more details.

Sorry about my earlier review- I was in a hurry and didn't do Ministix justice. The drawing does have a certain style to it. I am reviewing all your work (and raising your score with my true evaluation).
I do, in fact do Flash, I contribute to MEKoftheMEKkingdom and the Dragon/Spirit Alliance
I aim to bring out my first full collaboration in a few weeks.

Please try not to get into name calling- I am not your enemy, just a rather dark specialist in short subs.

[Ministix]

not too bad

For a whizzy scribble

Sheepeasy responds:

You know what pisses me off? When people who don't animate feel the need to comment on people's style of animating- so before you start giving this a 2 and complaining it's too scribbly; why don't you just piss off and get a copy of flash you neoyuppie scum bag!