IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Dendyn Dynasties]

Good but not great

I look forward to the real thing. I hope it has a decent storyline.

The animation looks great, but there's not much to go on really. I don't see what the fuss is all about; its not a patch on Chluiad and There She Is.

Please correct the spelling of EXCESSIVE.

[homer.swf]

Not my taste

Its well enough animated and I suppose a lot of other people found it funny. Theres nothing really wrong with it but I didn't find it funny and I certainly wouldn't have put it on front page, personally. Each to their own.

[LO Random Shorts]

Funny- nearly good enough

Yes, it was a funny little joke.

I would prefer it to have a little more to it to actually keep it on New Grounds- a little more animation- actually do somethjing with the shorts etc, maybe show more shorts on people, to make it more Random shorts instead of mostly shorts on the floor.

Good joke though

UrbanNinja06 responds:

hmm, i didnt really think about this much did i :(

[2 years of animation]

Ok but not brilliant

there is some quality animating in it and a lot of people do like random stuff. I do like the way it was put together very smoothly going form one to another.

however there is a limit to just what I could give something with no story or real point
-were this so-so quality animation from an unknown author it would be blammed with hostile reviews and you know it.

I certainly don't see why it was on Front Page. It doesn't even have any sounds apart from a track of music.

[Star Wars: Old Wounds]

Good stuff!

as a SW fan I loved it. As a Newgrounder I loved it too.

Please correct the word in the credits, I assume nobody did any action scropting!

[Flightless Birds FTW]

Not quite there

I think you need more to it. as you said, perhaps part of a compilation, or just add another animal or two two it.
Tiny shorts can make it, but they need to be exceptional. Please do work on it.
3/10 1/5

Crusty-Wiwuh responds:

Well it's through judgement, with a considerably higher score than 1/5, I dunno wether its worth adding to it... I guess I could do something real quick...

[Dark City Trailor]

Looks good

Looking forward to it. It might be quite thought provoking.

I clicked on the thing that told me to and nothing happened.

[Elmo Assasinator]

Yuk!

Not my taste at all, but it is exactly what you said it would be, so fair enough!

[Life of a Dead Chicken]

Seen worse

I guess you put some effort into it, but it didn't do anything for me. It didn't make any sense or entertain me at all. I couldn't see the point and it didn't look like a chicken at the beginning anyway, it looked like a canary head.

[Kingdom Hearts FP Preview]

Its OK.

I look forward to seeing the finished product. The cool modern music is right for some things, but not others. I really like the original music of KH it adds atmosphere.

The preview doesn't really tell us what you are going to do with KH, but it looks like it will be worth giving a viewing
4/10 0/5 (Tom doesn't like tests & previews- I don't think we want to keep them)