IceDragon64's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[WiFi Down : Foamy The Squirrel]

Ah, now this one took a little bit more effort than some of yours and has a really good good rant- spot on! I liked her responses too.

[RubberOnionBattle Nov 2018]

This is a good collab. Most are just bits of garbage that would not make it through judgement themselves. These made me smile. #3 definitely had it for me, such a sweet idea and so well done.

[People Cat People]

Still fairly basic, but I hope this is going somewhere. Vaguely amusing.

OK, I hope you develop this into something where the PCP are a distinctive group with their own characteristics- more I hope than just people with cat's heads.

[Forks - People Cat People Animated Short]

Welcome, Forks of the #People Cat People !!

It was a reasonable first go, with all the basics, including a vaguely humorous idea. I hope you can make something a bit less repetitive and more interesting next time.

Welcome People Cat People - from the Dragons & Spirits :)

[Total Scam]

Its OK. Tolerable animation/art. Sound is hard to hear in parts- repeated it twice and couldn't make it all out, but yeah, I'll just about Protect it.

[Draw Like an Idiot]

Can't say there is that much to it, but what there is is OK- sound, clear voice, a message worth saying, to a conclusion, pleasant music, nice enough art boxes ticked.

At first, I resisted the idea of it being "like an idiot" and then I accepted that putting it like that draws attention to the message and made me think. Obviously, as you explain it, it is not really "like an idiot", but from a perfectionist's point of view, not aiming for perfection might seem idiotic anyway, so yeah, I will go with this.

[Meaningless Messages : Foamy The Squirrel]

So-so. Its almost hypocritical really. Create a set of poses for the squirrel and reuse them again and again with a random background, talk about something anyone can say, make it high pitched and there is Foamy. You do some good ones, but this isn't really one of them. If this deserved Weekly 5th it must have been a crap week- you just get 5's for being Foamy.

There is nothing wrong with it as such. At least I can just about hear every word and there is a valid point made.

[Project: Infected Collab 2]

I don't specially like Madness, but I know a reasonable Madness when I see one. I am impressed to see a collaboration that is consistantly up to a good standard without any crap. I see all the bits and pieces one expects from cross-faced egg heads to posters etc.
None of it was actually that interesting or original excerpt for Gabriel- his spark of interest and the gag at the end were the only things that tipped it up into a rare 8/10 from me.

[Webcam confessions remake]

Its all there except, to me, any kind of point.

[Christmas Short]

Ticks all the boxes of a short, with everything in there- good voices, art, animation, music, mild humour.

"Various" is not good enough as a music credit, though. People want the credit for their work.