Score: 3

"Yes but no"

submission: Ludwig: the beginning

date: November 30, 2006

the 3d effect is impressive compared to the usual flash we see here, but what you've actually created seems pointless.
I am no expert but I assume this is not Flash but some other program, in which case, may I suggest you look for a more appropriate site.
We expect story/point
background. I imagine that this takes quite a bit of work to programme and I don't want to be unkind, but generally I come here to be entertained or educated and this does neither for me.
If this character were doing something more interesting on perhaps quite and ordinary but relevent background I would rate it much better.

Score: 6

"I eat cheese & jam- its cool!"

submission: Periodi City

date: November 29, 2006

Dragons & Spirits like weird food combinations and we support eduFlash, so its OK with me!

Periodicity fascinates me and you made a good effort. so much so I gave you a resonably good score, but you know its a mess.
the blue blocks of small letters are very hard to read, increase the contrast.
You need to tell everyone who the characters are at the end.

Score: 6

"Nice one!"

submission: Still the One

date: November 27, 2006

Its fun its funny. usually these personal things are crap, but yours is good. Don't be afraid that we wont understand or that its just for you two. Since you have chosen this song, which is all about Still Together, the video makes enough sense as it is, I would not have guessed most of it was about one particular person. In other words its stands as a good video of this song.
This version is not to my taste, I love the Shania Twain version and knowing that she wrote it from the heart about her husband helps some. The picture bit about growing old together was what pushed it up from 5/10 2/5 up to 6/10 3/5 for me.
Its true it doesnt have much actual animation, but it did tell a kind of story just the same so- Kewl!

Score: 4

"Lip Sync"

submission: Creepy Pilgrim Guy

date: November 25, 2006

The lip sync is wrong- He is say hella instead of hello. th O should be a smaller mouth.

Otherwise its ok if a bit pointless.

Score: 4

"Thank you very much for this"

submission: Tribute to Saddam

date: November 24, 2006

Very rare to see the alternaive perspective.

I was aware of some Saddams educational reputation, but the rest, including the award I did not know.

The world ought to take note of the fact that he still has a lot of supporters in Iraq, so he must have done something right for many thousands of people.

I would not put all the blame on Bush- some must go on Blair too and the ministers etc who didn't stand up against Bush and Blair.
If they had spent 1/10th on the peace that they spent on the war it would all be different.
As a flash its nothing special, its not much more than a slide show, but it is smooth enough, the english is OK and it definately deserves to stay to show that we are prepared to listen to this kind of thing.
I am not sure how to interprete your comment/photo of the Kurd graves, it seemed at odds witht he rest of the movie

Score: 6

"Very good little thing"

submission: -Wii-

date: November 23, 2006

Makes the Wii look good. Nice images. Good sound

Score: 8

"I liked it!"

submission: Rush 2 ++

date: November 23, 2006

Much better than Rush.

I do like random to a point, but this one was definately more developed. There was enough to see to get into and the little touches of sound matching action were good.

I recognise the girl from Hoy te Amo in there!

Score: 8

"Kewl! fun! Yay!"

submission: Hopelessly Romantic

date: November 23, 2006

Excellant short.

It makes it point perfectly, but I still think you might put in a background.

Score: 9

"Kewl"

submission: "Dare"

date: November 23, 2006

when you say three days- do you get any sleep in between? I mean, I have a full time job and all, but I couldn't do stuff this well if you gave me a month!

Its excellant
+interesting and inspiring interpretation of the music.
+great story
+great images
+satisfactory animation

Thank you,
Ice

Score: 10

"Like Inusfan..."

submission: The Spirit of Halloween 1

date: November 22, 2006

I tend to go into movies above Brackwood ready to vote them down to 'their proper place'...but...
All my five R belong to you today!

+Art
+detail
+animation
+timing
+Sound
+Character
This could be on TV.
I dont usually bother reviewing stuff where everyone's already said it all.
I seriously look forward to Ep 2
Well Done.
I would give you some constructive criticism if I could think of any.
Thanks,
Ice